Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sure, you don't personally need guns, but you do need physical safety at each end of the communication. Physical safety is provided by people with guns.


Those people can be policemen.


Police response times will never be low enough to be physically preventative outside of special areas (airports, stadiums, high traffic areas). It doesn't take that long to mug somebody.

Police violence is more of a way to discourage wrongdoing on the part of rational actors. Irrational actors (terrorists, mentally ill, drug-addled, enraged, desperate) probably won't be affected short of an oppressive police state.


Police has no requirement to protect. Also, there are people who live in areas where the police response time is 1+ hours even for the most drastic issues.


Just like with encryption, it might be the state actors you want to be protected from. So that argument is totally nosense.

If you buy that argument you could also argue that govermnets should be trusted as a holder of cryptogrphic keys.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: