Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I am grateful to my ancestors and countrymen for their self-sacrifice

I say "constructed identity", you say "I am grateful". If you twist my words to call them insane, that in itself says a lot about the security of your beliefs.

I have that gratitude, too, and I'm grateful to even more people who aren't my ancestors or countrymen. So why make that distinction? It's like saying "I'm grateful to the people with blue t-shirts who showed me kindness in life".



> I say "constructed identity", you say "I am grateful".

I'm not seeing your point. If it's that my gratefulness is "constructed", well, guilty as charged I guess. Love and most any other emotion people feel is "constructed".

> If you twist my words to call them insane, that in itself says a lot about the security of your beliefs.

You're the one who started with the insult, I simply returned the favor while pointing out the logical flaws in your reasoning for the insult.

> I have that gratitude, too, and I'm grateful to even more people who aren't my ancestors or countrymen. So why make that distinction?

That they're different seems sufficient reason.

> It's like saying "I'm grateful to the people with blue t-shirts who showed me kindness in life".

It might be, if people in blue t-shirts actually had showed me noteworthy kindness in life. But they haven't, so therefore it actually isn't like that, at least according to my logic.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: