Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Should we start rounding up Muslims too?

Our country is founded on a free market economy and competition. If a Chinese company outcompetes US companies... well that means our system is working.



>Should we start rounding up Muslims too?

If we decide that rounding up Muslims is a no good very bad idea it follows that we should probably try to do less business with those who do or at the very least do business on terms less favorable to them.


We may want to start with that as the official reason then instead of "national security." Trump is clearly not even trying to pretend to care about that issue.


> Should we start rounding up Muslims too?

I think the scope and actions matter. Responding to tariffs with tariffs makes perfect sense, for instance. Punishing individuals makes less sense (eg. if china decided to send all expat americans in china to concentration camps, doing the same to chinese americans wouldn't make sense).

>If a Chinese company outcompetes US companies... well that means our system is working.

It's a good sign that a US company can outcompete a chinese company, even with a handicap, but it's a not a desirable situation.


> Should we start rounding up Muslims too?

Some say yes, specifically some in the current administration... But ignoring my glib & pointless attack at a few powerful racists: this tangent of the tangent has very little to do with that the previous posters were saying.

The comparison would only be valid if rounding up the Muslim population has some effect on commercial interests specifically the giving commercial interests in the country doing the rounding up an advantage over those in the other country.


My point is that we shouldn't be copying the tactics of our competitors if we believe and accuse them to be wrong in the first place.

We've been accusing China of "unfair tariffs" when in reality we actually benefit from exploiting their cheap labor and sell them back the same iPhone they assembled for something like 10x the markup. Trying to say this is a reactionary tariff is disingenuous, when the trade balance has been in this state for decades, and the only real reason we're starting to ban their tech exports is because it's getting dangerously competitive with our own. It's shaking our foundational beliefs that our system is destined to win, and now we're resorting to the tactics of our rivals in a moment of insecurity.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: