Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

only 128GB, lol


Only costs a few hundred bucks for CPU ram. Sure it's slow, but for creative work it's competitive in speed with a human.


Humans run at approximately 100W, for 2 H100s you're looking at 600W-1400W. Plus humans have a much larger variety of capabilities. And they're more fun.

So you're paying ~10x the power costs to get worse, unverified, illogical answers faster when using LLMs vs humans. Which then have to be checked and revised by humans anyway.


>So you're paying ~10x the power costs to get worse

I mean I don't usually plug myself into an electrical outlet, isn't food much more expensive for the same amount of energy?


That is an interesting question. Where I live, the cost of electricity is 0.2276 €/KWh.

So the two H100, at 1KW, cost 0.2276×24 = €5.5 ($6) per day, which is nearly my groceries average.

(My meals are powering all of my body though, which is five times the consumption that my brain requires, so all in all, it seems a bit more power-efficient than the GPU still.)


However the LLM doing inference on 2 H100s can easily exceed 10x the content generation rate of a single human.

Regarding quality of the output, it obviously depends on the task, but we are benchmarking the models on real world metrics and they are beating most humans already.


This is a pretty cool and neat comparison that I haven't seen before. Probably worth including the rest of the server required to run 2 H100s because those aren't trivial either... I think the 100W might just be for an estimate of the human brain so maybe it is an equivalent example.

I know this isn't the spirit you meant it in, but I'm also impressed with humanity that we've managed to develop something as capable as it is (admittedly significantly less reliable and capable than a person) at only an order of magnitude difference in power consumption.


> Humans run at approximately 100W

I believe it's many times less for the brain. There's no way it dissipates anything close to 100W without cooking itself.


Sure, but brains aren't useful without the rest of the human.


What a deeply unnerving thread..


Brains are about 20W alone, but needs the rest of the body to run properly.


The brain is literally liquid cooled (blood), it can totally dispense of 100w of heat if it has to. (that said, other commenters are correct, the brain used 20w)


For a human as smart as Falcon 180B you'd probably need to pay at least $100k per year in the US.


And even then to get them to actually work as quickly would be impossible.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: