Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think the cry 'down with the hierarchy' is morally correct, and replacing a hierarchy with nothing is foolish. Structure does not need to have any hierarchy. We should think less in terms of pyramids (only a few at the top)... maybe consider the humble circle instead where those insulated from change affect less of it.


So you have a equal circle of many people. And the need for fast action, like it often can happen in real life.

Well, let's just say I have been part of many circles - but fast action was never the result of them, unless the circle was really, really small.

And even if there is no need for fast action - debating everything with everyone all the time for every decision - is somewhat timeconsuming and draining.


This is the first question posed by and to serious anarchists, and so one of the most frequently and thoroughly answered. There's value in thinking it through yourself but I suggest comparing solutions afterwards.


So ... will you give an answer with your own words and if possible, your own experience how this works out in reality, if it is seemingly so easy?

Like I said, I not just casually read and thought about it, for 5 minutes from the comfort of my couch. I took part in such circles (also in catalonia for example). And those are my findings.


I won't here, no.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: