Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | amgin3's commentslogin

Having 5+ companies each pouring billions into trying to make this technology a reality separately is ridiculous. All these companies should come together and work on a standardized single solution that can be shared between them. It will come much faster and be less expensive if they are pooling their resources.


Everyone here worships at the temple of competition


But what if they standardized on some compromise, as they tend to? That alone would set progress back, not foreward. Think if there are multiple orgs with billions to throw at it, the more the merrier. If there were just a few with a few million each, your plan makes much better sense. At some point the beuracracy of collectivism overshadows its usefulness.


I dare you to name a good technology that came about due to a race of proprietary competition and not in close collaboration with the best talent in the field. It really is a waste to bin all this engineering talent apart just because their free backpacks have a different logo embroidered. You could have two engineers struggling with the exact same problem sitting in the same uber pool ride to work and they wouldn't be able to speak a word of it to each other due to shortsightedness by shareholders. There will be a point where a clear winner emerges, 5 competing companies turns to 3 and turns to 1, and all those hours and hours of engineering effort by the failures becomes a moot point. It's not like the 1 company that emerges will hire another 5 companies worth of engineering either, this is redundant work. You wouldn't even be able to learn from these failures until decades after the fact in a blog post from a retired engineer no longer bound to an NDA.


AMP has totally ruined the internet for desktop users. ~90% of AMP sites don't even provide a link to the full desktop version of the page (unless you want to dig through the source code of the page, but even then it is hit and miss), and AMP sites are linked to more and more on social media sites like reddit.


I certainly hope not, the first "cat" I was shown had a human face.


447 comments here and not one questioning how this "mysteriously noisy galaxy" ended up being closer to us than Pluto.. (article says this galaxy is "3 billion miles away", Pluto is 4.67 billion miles from Earth).


AMP is terrible and it is ruining the web for desktop users. I frequently get linked to AMP pages while on my desktop, and have never come across one that provides a link to the non-AMP version of the page and often the URL to the non-AMP version cannot be derived from the AMP URL.

What's wrong with using CSS media queries to have a responsive design? Or if you absolutely need a separate mobile site for some reason, at least give a link back to the full desktop version of the page..

I get that AMP is supposed to help optimize page loading for mobile devices, but for most sites I don't think it is necessary to go to the extremes of AMP in 2018. Most places in the world have decent enough internet speeds and mobile data allowances that pages do not need to be super tiny all the time.


An AMP document is required to contain:

  <link rel="canonical" href="...">
pointing to the regular HTML document.


Except that doesn't put a physical link in the document. Why should I have to dig into the source code of the page just to find the link to the normal page?


Some non-mainstream browsers (ELinks at least) make <link>s visible. This is occasionally useful, but most of the time it just wastes space. :-/

You might want to use this web extension to make automatic AMP → HTML redirects:

https://github.com/da2x/amp2html

Or you could use this bookmarklet:

  javascript:window.location=document.head.querySelector('link[rel="canonical"]').href


By the time Bezos gets a rocket to the moon, Musk will already have a settlement on Mars.


Nuh uh!!! My billionaire can beat up your billionaire!!


This is a really stupid move. There are plenty of instances where websites do not need to use HTTPS, like simple static websites for small businesses that do not collect personal user information. This is going to cause a lot of confusion and outrage when it is implemented.


There are plenty of instances where websites do not need to use HTTPS

No there aren't.

like simple static websites for small businesses that do not collect personal user information

Until the connection gets MITMed to return a fake login page.


Please tell me a way to enable https for local LAN only devices that does not involve me MITM'ing every connection to them..


This centralizes publishing rights to browser vendors & security cert vendors. I don't want to take permission from any third-party before publishing content on the web.

In any case, its rather rude of you to presume to know what people should think about this topic.


What login page? Your typical company website just has a few pages of text without any active elements. Forcing those to buy SSL certificates creates just another artificial barrier to entry.


Whatever login page the attacker wants to present. They're betting percentages.

Google. Amazon. sac.mil. fed.gov. Whatevs.


HTTPS remains difficult to deploy for non-SWE web designers (i.e. the classic "webmaster" role).


Actually have to disagree with that. Currently "free SSL cert" is becoming part of every managed web hosting offering.


Alternative headline: "rich guy builds a house for his hipster hobby"


But in only five years, he was able to go from knowing nothing about photography, to spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on it!


Japan, China, and Korea are all heavily investing in Vietnam as well. In HCMC, Japan is building the first of nine rapid transit metro lines in the city, and in Hanoi China is doing the same.


This is BS. I lived in Vietnam for years, there are plenty of language schools where foreigners can go to learn Vietnamese. I've never heard of anyone needing a license to teach Vietnamese. There are even volunteer groups in HCMC for teaching foreigners Vietnamese, all done in the open with no teaching certifications.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: