Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more angerman's commentslogin

Ok. The idea is great, but as other have also said, the figures seem way off. Just two examples:

Basel being cheaper than Berlin? I have a hard time believing that.

But:

Hong Kong being cheaper than Leipzig? That just can't be true.


The price for Hong Kong looks weird, NomadCost per month in HK is roughly 350 EUR lower than the monthly rental costs. This is probably due to the very low listed price of the hostel and budget hotel rooms.


While not directly monad related. There's also instaparse (https://github.com/engelberg/instaparse) which has also pretty nice presentation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2AUW6psVcE

I just wanted to leave this here as if it hadn't been for twitter and the presentation, I would likely never have known about it.


Also, nobody cares. Since this comment is not even remotely related anymore.


That's basically a subscription model, no? Say USD80/12mo makes ~USD6.99/mo. I'm still not sure how I feel about renting software. Even though I feel that's where our industry is heading with the app stores and their restrictive pricing model.


Well, the issue many people have with renting software is that they can’t continue using it after they stop paying.

With what the grandparent proposed you wouldn’t have to upgrade, you could just continue using the old version.


I quite like the model where you get a year of major updates but can continue using the software after the year ends.

Seems to be popular with making developer tools for some reason. MonoTouch, RubyMotion and Apportable all use it, for example.


They'll keep updating, OK. But there's no backwards compatibility in the new format.

Sketch 2 can't open Sketch 3 files.

Somehow you're forced to update if you intent to keep using Sketch.


That's orthogonal to the pricing model. Same issue with pay-to-upgarade.


Perhaps they are doing something reasonable knowing that developers inevitably want to play with the new hotness and will upgrade.

I watch the phpstorm/pycharm EAP's like a hawk as they are constantly adding stuff that will make me hand over money :).


No, because users choose to upgrade and own the version they bought outright. You would also have different pricing for new users vs upgraders still, so you'd have the big up front bump from new users.

As you mention, some users don't like the "service" model, so you could present options along these lines (scale values to fit your product):

$120/yr ($10/mo) as a service, or... $150 to buy now with free minor upgrades and $100 (or scale to be fair for the magnitude of the upgrade) prorated major upgrades.

So I can choose to pay more up front and maybe save a little bit of money in the long run if I choose to keep upgrading, but definitely have access to the software I bought and am familiar with even if I decide I don't use it enough to keep upgrading.


I think this would also lead to a lot of users grabbing a subscription to try out the software who wouldn't have otherwise.

From there of of four things is likely to happen:

1) They decide they don't like it and end their subscription quickly. Since it was cheap, they don't feel cheated and are less likely to smear your brand.

2) They like it and are lazy/preoccupied/like-the-convenience, so they keep the subscription.

3) They like it enough they decide to buy a license so they can save some money long term with upgrades and have more freedom with how they use it.

4) They're not sure if they'll use it enough to justify a continued subscription. If they need it enough, they buy a license without planning to upgrade as a compromise. Maybe they'll decide to upgrade later. If they're not sure, they drop the subscription and maybe buy a month at a time when they need it in the future (you can encourage more frequent users not to do this by offering a 20-25% discount to prepay a year for the service).

Monolithic desktop software like this would pull in more users and revenue with flexible rent/buy options.

I'm also more confident that you're motivated to keep pushing out big meaningful upgrades if you have users that you actually actively have to convince to buy them over what they already have.


> That's basically a subscription model, no?

Not really. A subscription model means the software stops working when you stop paying. @entrode's pro-rating idea is just more granular about how much of a rebate you get off the next version.


It usually means that, but not necessarily. Unreal Engine 4 does a $20/month subscription where you can stop paying at any time and just keep using the version you have.

Maybe they do that because it would be impossible to enforce anything else (paying one month gets you the full source code), but it's still great that the license allows it.


Do you want others to implement your idea as well?


Our main goal is to help spread the word and see others using this technique. Implementation is not so difficult since only a hash, but if you want to contribute or implement it, sure.


Now. Where do I get this for my kindle? Add a play/pause button and a (continuous) knob to tune the speed (with reverse?). An option to jump back a sentence or a paragraph? Or show me the current position on the actual page? (Some way to make spacial position meaningful.) And I'm pretty sure I'm sold.


And I think Amazon would like their customers to read more books, too...


Sounds like it's faster. And allows to reattach to a certain session.


Isn't that what NX does as well?


Yes. If you're already using NX there's nothing to see here.


It may not matter to you, but xpra feels a lot more light-weight than NX. Installing/using xpra feels like tmux or ssh. NX feels like an enterprise software suite.


It definitely matters. I've always struggled with NX. VNC is easier, but slower.


NX has a "rootless" mode, and a "desktop" mode. xpra has only the "rootless" mode.


That's just not true anymore. You can get a desktop mode by running Xephir inside xpra.


Bah now we're into semantics, but say you're running xpra on display :1. Running an Xnest or Xephyr inside that can't re-use the :1 display. Further, you can run multiple Xnests/Xephyrs inside an xpra session.

I stand by my statement that xpra has only a "rootless" mode, but I will agree that with Xephyr (which is a less-sucky Xnest), there is less of a difference anymore.


Thanks for the pointer. I'm still running the pre evernote sketch, but it's starting to show it's age.


Could you please elaborate on this a little more? How did German and Finnish derive from Sanskrit? Could you give examples?


Derived from Sanskrit is probably wrong, but German, Finnish and Sanskrit belong to the Indo-European language family (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-european). Sanskrit is a very old language in this family tree (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Indo-European_language) and thus very close to the common ancestor. Being close to the ancestor probably means that it shares many traits with it that were inherited by other Indo-European languages.

Kinda like how knowing Latin makes it easier to learn Romanic languages (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanic_languages), but Romanic languages were really derived from Latin.


Finnish is Uralic, not Indo-European.


Oops, thanks. For a possible relationship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Uralic_languages


Russian too.


That's what was my take from the article as well, it focused on performance base on single-sex vs. coed school education. Would this be an issue as well, if we had mandatory clubs and after school (coed) activities as well. Are we not confusing two things here? On the one hand, because the mandatory institution we have is school, and we consider getting to know the other sex an important part while growing up, we conclude that school should be coed, so to force the latter intent? Also, isn't interest in the other sex somewhere natural and could result in a higher after school coed activity (clubs, sports, ...) in those going to single-sex schools?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: