Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | aramsh's commentslogin

This was already posted by the way! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46278421


https://archive.is/pvY47 archive link for those who dont want to pay


I'm not endorsed by this, just thought it was interesting it got into YC...


It's almost unbelievable that something so stupid is getting VC funding: "because some programmers lack impulse control we'll move the distractions into the IDE".


We are post-peak YC, which appears to be using more of a spray and pray approach these days. (much larger batches, much less advisor time)


this is bizarre. The only thing in the page is a download link which obviously we will not install in my computer.


FYI Hack Club helps fiscally sponsor organizations that do not have the capacity to apply for nonprofit status (https://hackclub.com/fiscal-sponsorship/). The 7% income covers dev fees for lawyers, engineers and a bunch of other stuff to help it kept running.


Hi, Hack Clubber here. Fun fact: The 7% does not completely cover the cost of running a fiscal sponsorship program like HCB! That fee does not make HCB a net positive product to run in terms of cost. It just helps offset it a little.


Hack Club was on a grandfathered free nonprofit plan, but switched to a 5k/year on earlier this year under a special deal with Slack. Now the price is increased to 50k one time, and then 200k a year


Why did they switch? Given the information provided, it seems that paying anything, if you're on a grandfathered free plan, is a bad deal.


Slack moved us off the free plan to the 5k plan, which is fair considering thousands of users; it costs money to host those servers.


There is no obligation to provide the "grandfathered" free plan forever, they could have taken that away too. Presumably they switched to get some features they wanted that weren't on their old plan. Slack can take away the old deal as easy as the new, staying on the old is no guarantee Slack will let you keep it forever.


Right - there is so much context missing. Extrapolating just a little, it looks like the story is something more like "We had too many users for our existing free plan, so we switched to a paid plan that had a first-year discount of 97%. We didn't really pay attention to the fine print, and now we've got a nasty letter demanding lots of money."

Not defending Slack / Salesforce. You just can't deal with them with that level of naivety.


i don't know if your surmises are correct. But my point is just that this seems irrelevant to Slack ending the deal. If they had stayed on the existing "grandfathered" plan, Slack could still be ending it. So I don't see the relevance. There's no reason to think they would be safer if they had stayed on a "grandfathered" plan that isn't even offered anymore, in fact it's often safer to switch to a currently offered plan if they're offering you a reasonable one, figuring they'll end the grandfathered one sooner than a currently offered one. That alone could be reason to switch in fact.


Right. The sensible thing to do would have been to develop a migration strategy as soon as you hear words like "grandfathered" or "first-year discount".


What's even more interesting is there is no DNS records for important.g.co, which means they have found a way to create an Google Workspace without verifying the domain but still able to send emails like password resets.

It's definitely a glitch where you can send emails/transactional emails from an unverified Google Workspace. My guess is that their are protections for google.com and google domains but they forgot to add the g.co domain, which allows unverified sending to g.co and creation of workspaces.


Hack Club has absolutely changed my life, I live in a suburban area and there are not many people interested in tech but Hack Club has allowed me to find people like me. I’ve done things I’ve never thought I would do and it’s been such a great thing in my life.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: