Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more azuajef's comments login

Well said.


Apart from the historical value of this submission, imagine nowadays a scientific paper starting with "Imagine...". Thanks for sharing!


He's just using it as a synonym for "Consider..." or "Assume we have...", which is a really common way to start. I didn't find this paper to read very differently from a contemporary paper in Physical Review Letters, except that there's no introduction that gives context within the rest of the literature.

Using the word "imagine" isn't that unusual. Here's some examples in just the past couples of years:

"We might then imagine other starting points which..."

"...let us now imagine that..."

"Let us imagine a potential of the form..."

https://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2015&q=imagine&hl=...


To me it read more like a math text than a physics text, in which "let there be X...", "imagine Y...", and similar phrases, are usually found. Yet I agree, it seems the physics community has grown a slight alergy to that kind of writing, and it probably would be received with a bit of skpeticism/disdain nowadays.


And the same can be said about other communities, inc. computing and biology.


Nothing special about the "imagine" portion; plenty of research in theoretical Computer Science takes an even more informal.approach in the introduction.


Nice reference. Thanks for sharing.


This is a key point, well said. However, we need more people who are proficient in both "worlds" or at least, as another user points out below, more people willing to collaborate.


A nice variety of approaches. Any plans for implementing others, e.g., Smith-Waterman and mutual info. similarities?


Thanks for sharing. I also recommend "An Introduction to Statistical Learning - with Applications in R": http://www-bcf.usc.edu/~gareth/ISL/


A direct link to the PDF for ISL is here:

https://web.stanford.edu/~hastie/local.ftp/Springer/ISLR_pri...

The grownup version of that, ESL, is also available free:

https://web.stanford.edu/~hastie/local.ftp/Springer/ESLII_pr...

And for people who are genuinely curious about how this segues into graphical models, NNs, and the autoencoder (maybe the most interesting part of modern NNs), there's

https://web.stanford.edu/~hastie/StatLearnSparsity_files/SLS...

The more curious or research oriented may appreciate

https://web.stanford.edu/~hastie/local.ftp/hastie_glmnet.pdf

I doubt Gareth or Daniela (the primary authors of ISL) would mind my pointing you towards Hastie's archives since both of them were advised by Trevor Hastie during their PhDs.

Matloff is a great guy. The chapters on shrinkage and dimension reduction aren't yet written in his book, and since these are important topics, you should consider reading the others. These things are mostly of interest for people who want to draw inference about underlying processes that may be generating observed outcomes. If all you care about is prediction, fit a Random Forest or xgboost GBM or a DNN and be done with it. But if you're actually curious about how complex descriptions of rare events can be thoughtfully analyzed, this is the standard progression.

Matloff's book is a great introduction. I particularly like the example on page 204. /ducks


In the bio/health/bio-info areas: a key option is to create alerts with http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed


Yes, and Google Scholar alerts are also useful and pick-up slightly different things. Good to have both



I thought the recent Onion article "Encouraging New Study Indicates Majority Of U.S. Students Can Now Recognize Math" was satire... but perhaps sadly it isn't as far-fetched as it seems.

http://www.theonion.com/article/encouraging-new-study-indica...


by that logic - algebra is a word from arabic, al jabr, if you follow it to its ultimate conclusion of somebody with a racist myopic worldview, arabic = desert and camels and guys with swords = terrorism = ISIS


Keep going... Lock up everyone who uses those radical Arabic numerals then?


Also chemistry/alchemy comes (sortof) from the Arabic "al-kīmiyā" - or further back, from the Egyptian name for Egypt.

So any chemist reading books on "Free Radicals" should be questioned immediately!


let's ban elephants while we're at it, since elephant is derived from the arabic "al feel". Also Giraffes, arabic "zarafa"


This is also my initial impression. But is there any published study in favor or against this view?


But even for programmers, I wonder if start-ups are actually generating sufficient jobs now.


Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: