Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more jpeter's commentslogin

Impressive way to gather more training data



I mean you can always use the dotnet CLI if you want


Perhaps more to the point, you can also use the filesystem view and edit the config files manually rather than by GUI magic if you prefer (or if you need to diagnose a problem in a solution resulting from different projects having people do different magic GUI things, because comparing files side by side is much easier.)


FAA gives Boeing a free pass


Next step is to use all of YouTube to train Gemini 2.0.


As long as it doesn't regenerate (I don't think google will allow it), for video analysis, it is totally within google's rights to do it.


As a german trust me, the regulations are a good thing. When I drive at night, there are so many cars in oncoming traffic that dazzle you with their led headlights


You these automatic ones are terrible. Fundamentally they tone down after they see your headlights which is too late.

Especially when you stick your head over an hill top.

I think they should be banned, as a traffic danger.


I am thinking of Stargate SG-1 Season 11. And remaking Game of Thrones after Season 5


and not having to wait months if you live in EU


What's worse is that I can't seem to find a way to let Google know where I actually live (as opposed to where I am temporarily traveling, what country my currently inserted SIM card is from etc). And apparently there is no way to do this at all without owning an Android device!

Apple at least lets me change this by moving my iTunes/App Store account, which is its own ordeal and far from ideal, but at least there's a defined process: Tell us where you think you live, provide a form of payment from that place, maybe we'll believe you.


Yeah Google aggressively uses geolocation throughout their services, regardless of your language settings. The flipside of that is that it's really easy to access the latest Gemini or whatever by just using a VPN.


Wait, does that mean if I subscribe to Gemini Pro in country A where it's available (e.g. the US) but travel to Europe, I can't use it?

I'm really frustrated by Google's attitude of "we know better where you are than you do". People travel sometimes and that's not the same thing as moving!


I signed up for all of their AI products when I was in the US, some of them work while I'm out of country some don't. I can't tell what the rule is...


I really, really hate all of these geo heuristics. Sure, don't advertise services to people outside of your market, I get that. Do ask for a payment method from that country too to provide your market-specific pricing if you must.

But once I'm a paying customer, I want to use the thing I'm paying for from where I am without jumping through ridiculous hoops!

The worst variant of this I've seen is when you can neither use nor cancel the subscription from outside a supported market.


To be clear, I didn't pay for any of them. I just signed up for early access to every product that uses some form of ML that can remotely be called "AI"...

Once I got accepted, some of them work outside of the US and some don't


OpenAI has no Moat


A reference to the good doc: https://www.semianalysis.com/p/google-we-have-no-moat-and-ne...

While I'm linking semianalysis, though, it's probably worth talking about how everyone except Google is GPU poor: https://www.semianalysis.com/p/google-gemini-eats-the-world-... (paid)

> Whether Google has the stomach to put these models out publicly without neutering their creativity or their existing business model is a different discussion.

Google has a serious GPU (well, TPU) build out, and the fact that they're able to train moe models on it means there aren't any technical barriers preventing them from competing at the highest levels


they also have internet.zip and all of its repo history as well as usenet and mails etc.. which others don't.


but GPT-4 is nearly a year old now, I'd wait for the next release of OAI before judgement. Probably rather soonish now I would expect.


You were right i guess :)


They only have a head start, and the lead is closing


hence why it's Open


This. He’s right you know.

OpenAI is extremely overvalued and Google is closing their lead rapidly.


Is there any meaningful valuation on OpenAI? It’s not for sale, there is no market.

Google … has no ability to commercialize anything. Their only commercial successes are ads and YouTube. Doing deceptive launches and flailing around with Gemini isn’t helping their product prospects. I wouldn’t take a bet between open ai and anyone, but I also wouldn’t take a bet on Google succeeding commercially on anything other than pervasive surveillance and adware.


> Is there any meaningful valuation on OpenAI? It’s not for sale, there is no market.

Its shares are already for sale on private markets for accredited investors and for a valuation of over $100BN lead by Thrive Capital.

> Google … has no ability to commercialize anything.

Absolute nonsense.

So Google Cloud, Android (Play Store) are not already commercialized? You well know that they are.

> Doing deceptive launches and flailing around with Gemini isn’t helping their product prospects.

Gemini already caught up to (and surpassed) GPT-4V. What is your point?

> I wouldn’t take a bet between open ai and anyone, but I also wouldn’t take a bet on Google succeeding commercially on anything other than pervasive surveillance and adware.

OpenAI's greatest competitor is Google DeepMind which has the advantage of Google's infrastructure to scale up their models quickly and they have direct access to Google's billions. OpenAI cannot afford to make mistakes or delay anything and a single mistake can cost them hundreds of millions of dollars. The majority of the investment from Microsoft is in Azure credits and not in dollars. [0]

[0] https://www.semafor.com/article/11/18/2023/openai-has-receiv...


But what we know for certain is that at some point in the early 21st century all of mankind was united in celebration. We marveled at our own magnificence as we gave birth to AI.


Plot Twist:

- AI is not smart enough to take over humanity.

- But by playing god with geoengineering by having rain packed with sulfur on our crops, we are facing The Blight, like in Interstellar.


You know what they say: Artificial intelligence is no match for natural stupidity...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: