Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | superos's comments login

Hi, let's create some unemployment. Each and every time the low paid gets in a position to demand a higer salery this happens. Amerika all over again.


I just can't get used to that search field in the title bar (you can see it in several applications e.g AppCenter first screenshot). IMHO it should be more prominent centered top in the main content area, not (almost greyed out?) in the title bar next to the maximize/restore button (why?). Just weird. What GUI guidelines are stipulating this?


The irony; Bernard Madoff dies, but his spirit lives on.


True. And the whole initial point of Bitcoin BTC is gone. Bitcoin BTC is now first and foremost a pretty poor digital ponzi scheme(with fees it is actually a negative sum game). Bitcoin SV tries to fix this, but it is still a PoW system and thus not what we want when fighting to save our earth from negative climate change.


I switched 20 years ago. What took them so long?


uh you're just 1 person?


I loved him because he was a proper guitar geek. Owner of a lot of vintage stuff and really a good player too. A lot of people wanted him to buy and revive Gibson.


At my workplace most (not all!) smart people wants to do the real sh*t. ie design, programming etc. They do not want to be a manager because that means there is no time to do what they love, and have to do management instead (meetings, more meetings, budgets, meet other managers (BORING!), attend management gatherings and conference (EVEN MORE BORING) etc).


Why didn't he call his new magazine "The Echo Chamber"?


That’s accurate. Articles are peppered with first person pronouns. Minimalist on presentation AND content, sadly.


Thanks for that reminder. We might see iBooks versus all other vendors using EPUB3 then.


I tried to follow this announcement through the web today and I noticed a few things I would like to comment on as an educational technologist.

1. It did not impress me (iBooks). Looked like gorgeous Apple design on 'CDROM' type educational software we used to have in the old days.

2. I liked the glossary and notes/annotations that turned into summary cards for learning.

3. Interactive features are added using Keynote(?)

or

4. You need to know 'HTM5' and Javascript to do interactive stuff (this is not GarageBand for eLearning as someone told me it would be).

5. The way iBooks Textbooks are now part of iTunes U does add a lot to iTunes U. Now it can disrupt LMS (Learning Management Systems) vendors as well.

6. I still love eInk.

Then some worries.

7. What happened to epub and similar standards?

8. Is this new format a lovely zip file we can extract and inspect?

9. Is it possible to read iBooks on other devices/platforms?

10. Am I allowed to share my iBooks with friends and relatives?

11. Will my grandchildren be able to read my iBooks in 50 years time?


(edited for readability)

1. Go to an Apple store and use it. Its nothing like a CDROM encyclopedia. Encarta comes to mind. The richness of Apple's Textbook experience is definitely immersive and, like most of their products, can't be perceived until you actually use it for a while.

3. Interactive features can be a movie, HTML(5), 3D, or, yes, a Keynote presentation. Imagine a richer image gallery type experience, but with text, transitions, effects, etc. All this can be done w/ Keynote (and a little bit of visual design know-how) right now.

4. Not basic Keynote-style interactive stuff like I described above. You need to be able to produce and edit movies to add a movie. You need to be able to use 3-D software to make a 3-D model. This is obvious stuff. Multiple disciplines go into making even paper textbooks.

6. eInk IS great... for long-format reading. K-12 and Undergrad textbooks never really involve that much long-format reading. Plus Apple is trying to really show that there are alternative ways to learn besides reading. Getting immersed in the subject matter — whether that's through video, audio, games, text, or anything — is the real threshold to learning.

7. iBook is based on the ePub3 standard. I think they're one in the same, but with different headers.

8. See above.

9. No. Never will be.

10. No. Probably will never be able to.

11. No. Textbooks won't exist in 50 years as all knowledge will grow into your brain from a bionano parasite injected into all humans upon birth.

OK, now to take 9,10, and 11 more seriously:

As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, textbooks are hugely expensive and are NOT designed to last forever. They contain proprietary information owned by a publisher who has the right to let you not share it. I'm sure some version of these books will be stored in the Library of Congress forever. And much of the material is probably available online or at the library in one way or another. Isn't that fine?

Apple is ushering in a new wave of education materials reform that costs LESS than the current model and is practically weightless. Who cares that you can't pass it on or share it. Its practically disposable.


Actually, it is probably yes on 11 (50-year down the track). Unless Apple encrypted the format, it is epub3 - zip file with html, xml, and other standard-based formats in there. Unzip, extract, modify, recreate under emulator. Same story as OpenOffice.org. Much better than than MSWord formats and - frankly - much better than books from 50 years ago, which if you wanted to do any "modern" thing with (e.g. searching), you would have to rip apart, scan, do text-recognition, layout-reconstruction, etc.

Now, if Apple has put a real DRM/Encryption in there, it would be quite another story. Even then, 50 years down the track, any digital modern encryption will probably be a 10-second crack away.


> Now, if Apple has put a real DRM/Encryption in there, it would be quite another story.

I'm pretty sure iBookStore ebooks are DRM'd (same as Kindle files) (EPUB has a provision specifically for DRM, FWIW) but according to an other commenter the .ibook output of iBook Author is an epub3 book, you can just change the file extension and drop it into an ebook reader (though Apple has apparently added e.g. CSS extensions for nifty effects, which your ebook reader likely won't support).


> 6. I still love eInk.

I do too, but for a novel. For a next-generation textbook, I'd rather have videos, animations, interactive materials. It sucks at sunlight, but again I study at my room and maybe that'll change in a few years.

> 8. Is this new format a lovely zip file we can extract and inspect?

Do you think that publishers that sell you a physical book for $119 would let you inspect their digital books and possibly re-sell them?

> 9. Is it possible to read iBooks on other devices/platforms?

It might be. I think it depends on what publishers want (DRM'ed or non-DRM'ed).

> 10. Am I allowed to share my iBooks with friends and relatives?

In the future, I'm sure you will.

> 11. Will my grandchildren be able to read my iBooks in 50 years time?

If YOU bought them, sure (that is, if Apple is still around). If your school bought them for you, probably not.


I've just made a .ibooks file, and if you unzip it it's just a normal epub3 file (I think). The mime type is application/x-ibooks+zip.

If it's not epub (not 100% familiar with format), it's just xhtml, css, svg, some plists and all your assets (jpgs, pngs, etc)


That is interesting. So far so good :-)


Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: