Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | thwave's comments login

> Proclus (ca. 335 BC)

Proclus, whose quote opens the section on Euclid, lived more than 700 years after this date, well into the 5th century AD. Euclid himself wasn't born till about decade after, in 325 BC.


That is true. I've updated the info, though I couldn't quite find the exact date of the publication of "Proclus' Commentary on the First Book of Euclid's Elements".

Good catch! Thanks for the heads-up!


There's always inference.


Unless gratefulness is actually binary (x is grateful for y), and directing this gratefulness towards someone is completely optional. (One might argue that the object of gratefulness is optional as well, and you can be grateful simpliciter, in an unqualified way. But to them I'd say there's an implied, general, object: the world, life, existence, or something like this.)


There are still some scholarly work written in Latin. For example see Terence O. Tunberg's book from 2013[0].

I highly recommend this[1] blog post about contemporary Latin knowledge.

[0]https://www.amazon.com/rationibus-colloquendi-Supplementa-Hu... [1] http://blogicarian.blogspot.com/2019/03/argumentum-ad-ignora...


Correct. The translated sentence ("my son was a gude and honourable mon, but Sparta has mony a mon better than him.") does ends with two distinctly Doric words: τήνω (there, i.e. in Sparta) κάρρονας (stronger/better), instead of the Attic ἐκεῖ κρείττονας.


> "my son was a gude and honourable mon, but Sparta has mony a mon better than him."

On a sidenote, this sounds northern irish to me. Think Daniel Day-Louis in The Boxer


Thanks! Fascinating that the translator chose to represent the dialectal bits explicitly with a contemporary dialect, even though the style of the translation is not all contemporary. And the contemporariness makes the intent hard to understand without reading a bunch of footnotes (or ancient Greek) only a few decades later.


This footnote refers to Sayings of Kings and Commanders[0], another text of Plutarch, but is not related to the translation.

[0] https://www.loebclassics.com/view/plutarch-moralia_sayings_k...


That's 190 C. It might be this bit about Doric somethingorother

https://i.imgur.com/oV88mWG.png



My piano teacher used to say "It's not a video-game, you don't go back to the beginning of the level every time you lose."


There's a very interesting comparison to be made between Wittgenstein and Spinoza, but saying something like "basically just a rehash" completely missed the point. Saying that Spinoza is "just a rehash" of Stoic ideas is a bit more correct, and still not very interesting outside of a very specified discussion.

The title "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus" was not Wittgenstein's idea, but Moore's.


> not brew, that one is also spyware

how is brew spyware?


It transmits your on-device activity to Google without consent. It includes a unique tracking identifier generated on install that never changes, like a supercookie. Every time you run brew, it transmits this to Google, which allows Google to assemble a city-level tracklog of your device based on client IP geolocation, along with a list of all the packages you have installed, and when.

It does this silently, and without obtaining any sort of consent, which is why most people are unaware that homebrew is spying on them.


I’m not sure where you get your facts?

> You will be notified the first time you run brew update or install Homebrew. Analytics are not enabled until after this notice is shown, to ensure that you can opt out without ever sending analytics data.

- https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics


Yes, it says this once at install time, and does not obtain any form of consent to spying.

Then, at runtime, it proceeds to silently transmit the data each time you run brew.


I'm confused- the brew developers say you can run `brew analytics off` to "prevent analytics from ever being sent" [1]. Is this not accurate? Are analytics still being sent? Is your concern with the consent, or are the brew developers lying when they say this command prevents analytics from being sent?

1: https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics


I think what he means is that there isn't explicit consent given for the analytics, as in opt-in rather than opt-out. You can disable it but that's not the same.


When they implemented it, they opted everyone in and buried the notice in a wall of text. I only caught it when Little Snitch notified me that brew was reaching out to Google.

The project still doesn't seem to understand how bad of a mistake this was and how bad their response to it was. But as the project lead told us while playing the victim, if we're not contributors, our opinions on the matter mean nothing.


Why to Google?


You'd have to ask the homebrew developers that.

Every time I've ever seen anyone question their decision to embed Google spyware in their product, however, the GitHub issues are closed and locked, so I don't know if you'll have very good luck. I stopped trying to convince them to behave ethically and simply use nixpkgs now instead (which incidentally in my experience works better) and do my best to inform people about the facts so they can make their own decisions (something I wish homebrew would do, instead of deciding for them to use their computer to spy).


It uses Google Analytics.


So the GP is wildly overblown? How is Google Analytics spyware?


What is spyware to you? If it's spying on me without consent and sending private information about my computer it is definitely spyware, regardless of the database they use.

Since they don't ask for consent and uses PII, it is illegal under GDPR, probably CCPA and other laws too. It's also Not Nice™.


What private information about your computer is it sending? Browser, OS, screen size, location, ISP. Under GDPR, and the way i see things, none of that is PII.


It generates a unique identifier which it transmits on each invocation. The identifier uniquely identifies the installation of homebrew, linking all of those other bits of data together across time and space.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: