Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more vmurthy's commentslogin

A few things that stand out (not that it's that shocking!)

- Narratives matter -- a lot . Second order effects of such subjective rankings are real . Imagine getting a credit downgrade because someone perceives the democracy to be under threat

- "the government had reverse-engineered the ranking, strategically identifying procedural tweaks that directly boosted India’s scores in Delhi and Mumbai—the two cities evaluated by the World Bank" .

I love the whole cynical nature of this. This is statecraft at it's finest ( I render no moral judgements here :) ). This is reminiscent of Machiavelli or Kautilya (Chanakya) [0]

A lot more to digest but will post them as a reply on this thread.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chanakya


Statecraft at its finest? Next, I'll hear that KPI manipulation sets the standard for good engineering...


I don’t know, I get the feeling Sir Humphrey would approve of this fine piece of statecraft (unless of course it was an adversary of Her Majesty’s government, in which case he would be appropriately concerned)


I agree re KPIs and engineering. But, statecraft is people. You’re not dealing with bits :)


The real question is why did anyone even think KPIs were effective in the first place.


Exactly, I'm sure Boeing and Intel both had KPIs coming out the walls but both have had major engineering issues recently.


I like the general idea. I read the book “Start with no” a long time ago and the lessons stuck. The first principle here is that people have an innate need for autonomy and giving them the option to say no gives them peace of mind. Highly recommended.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/689417


I rarely cry when I read (or in general) but the poignancy of this article was too much . I remember how many changes my wife's body went through during our second pregnancy . Juxtapose all the things that Bess went through, it is too cruel to even think of . Have strength Bess <3


It maybe that this works for you individually, but does it work well as part of a team? I think it's one of those cases where one needs to do what is convenient for most of the team rather than one member?


Are there people for whom it works better to have nearly as many folders as files?


I'd argue that if you are really interested, you can follow a few academics and read up on their papers etc. Of course, that's a big undertaking but it's the only alternative I can think of given the incentives for pushing shit at us


That's just subjecting yourself to more marketing. They're trying to sell you their theory and get you to cite it or even better fund the work.

It's quite common to gloss over arguments or ignore data that don't support their cause.


I feel like this is equivocating a bit. Scientific papers exist to put forth an argument and change minds, yes. That’s the entire point of science as an endeavor. It’s not perfect, but if we’re going to define “marketing” as “anytime someone tries to convince me of anything”, I think we’re getting a tad reductionist.


> I mean, once people finish the work that needs to be done, and if there isn't any more work to be done... those people get let go

Except , companies tend to hire and fire rather periodically which is a huge waste in terms of "lead time" (it takes an employee x months to be productive) not to mention demoralizing to employees. The alternative seems to be to have better planning or a decent enough roadmap rather than cater to the whims of Wall St ?


I can understand the business imperatives (I am a PM at a start-up :)), but can you please make a decision on actually having the sign up flow work without friction (Think Slack / dropbox etc). You can always iterate and find the right thing to charge for but developers are a demanding bunch especially with tooling!


Does your org have teams for InfoSec? Something tangential like Offensive Security[0] certs might help portray interests beyond your core work but not too far removed either :) . Plus the certs are really really good as per people who work in InfoSec

[0] https://www.offsec.com/pricing/


One has to wonder if the Nobel prize was a mistake. Even if it was, no , a Nobel prize can't be revoked as per this[0]

[0]https://www.nobelprize.org/frequently-asked-questions/#:~:te....



In many ways though, I think it's a strength that such a prize cannot be revoked, because it emphasizes the zeitgeist of a time. I think it can help provide not only some humility to us in a different era, but also perhaps help us learn more from the past.

As an interesting factoid, lobotomy was practiced at all levels of society at the time. Even JFK's sister was secretly lobotomized [1]. It was covered up for years as it went about as well as one would expect a lobotomy to go.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosemary_Kennedy


What a story, I never knew about this. Again and again these public families with public images doing the most toxic things behind closed doors. Thanks for sharing this.


But Moniz's case isn’t a case of fraud , no? I’m not insinuating this case is fraud fyi


I was hoping to learn the tricks and tips of the trade ( QA) but the article deals with someone's experience as a QA in gaming. Good read , though , in case you are in interested in anecdotes etc :).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: