Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> why do the choices that women (or any given group) make result in them being paid less overall?

If you pick a low-valued career, you will probably be paid less. No need to bring in gender here... movers are mostly men, and they're also low-value.

> Should they essentially be punished for those choices, particularly when you consider the power that money buys?

It's not punishment. They willingly give up the power of money by picking a career that earns less. If someone wants the power of money, pick a different career. Again, gender doesn't matter.

> Are some of the occupations that are dominated by women undervalued and underpaid, such as teaching and nursing?

Yes, but it has nothing to do with the dominating gender. Those fields are just under appreciated... it's a societal problem if we under value those professions, but (again) gender doesn't matter. Male nurses suffer the same problem.

It seem what you should be asking is: Are women inherently biased to pick these nurturing roles, and is this because of societal or biological pressures? If it's biological, is society responsible for correcting the economic imbalance by effectively subsidizing those roles? Should we accept that some careers are valued less, make this very obvious during formative years (highschool/college), encourage rational decision making, and accept any natural gender imbalances that result?



>It has nothing to do with the dominating gender.

If ${group} is valued less in society then it isn't a stretch that ${activities group does} becomes less valued in society.

Many here are quick to point out that weed was outlawed because it was an activity that minorities enjoyed.

I'm not saying that this is the case (idk) but its not an outlandish idea.


>If ${group} is valued less in society then it isn't a stretch that ${activities group does} becomes less valued in society.

We don't pay people based on how we "value" them. Labor is a market like any other.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: