Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>P.S. Downvotes for this question? Really?

There are always people on HN who love being contrarian and trying to diminish amazing things. It's like they hate seeing people excited for something and want to point out that this isn't that big of a deal.

We're literally watching things happen for the first time ever, and this person's response is "what's so great about this?" while implying that people who are excited about this are fanboys. I can understand the downvotes honestly.



We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11643617 and marked it off-topic.


This is a new thing, 2-3 years ago downvotes were still rare, these days people treat it like reddit where it means disagree rather than inappropriate. The culture's changed.


The karma threshold for downvotes likely means that there are far more people with the ability than there were 3 years ago. Honestly, I only collected enough karma recently to down vote (and it's a privilege I use quite sparingly).


Downvoting to express disagreement is sort of officially correct, though:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

Not that I agree with that at all.


How do you even see downvotes?


The text turns grey if something is being downvoted. If it's downvoted too much it'll eventually go [dead] and you need to turn on showdead in you profile to see it.


>diminish amazing things..

Sorry. We are living in a period where mediocrity and even complete fraudulent stuff is hailed as profound and "amazing". People with differing opinions matter, and I would say they matter more than ever.

And I don't think people love being a contrarian". It is quite easy being a fanboy, but it is hard to go against popular opinion, and be a "contrarian". There is no love in being a contrarian, there is only hate and ridicule.


Even easier than being a fanboy is to promote one's own superiority via dismissal and sneering at the efforts of others. You probably see yourself as sophisticated, but your remarks are no different than a 7 year old putting down somebody for throwing like a girl.

It's adolescent, not contrarian.


Please don't respond in kind when someone else is name-calling. Instead, flag the comment (by clicking on its timestamp to go to its page, then clicking 'flag') or email us at hn@ycombinator.com.


>Even easier than being a fanboy is to

Easier? How? Because you said so?

>promote one's own superiority via dismissal

How come I haven't noticed that it isn't working, then?

>sneering at the efforts of others..

This is where you show your fanboy colors. The GP said something along the line "I don't think that is as amazing as you say", and you overreact, saying that they are, "sneering at others efforts". Another commenter said SpaceX is facing "incredible" criticism in HN. All signs of over reaction, typical of fanboys when their need and expectation of unquestioning acceptance and praise from everyone, for their object of worship, are not met..

>You probably see yourself as sophisticated, remarks are no different than a 7 year old putting down somebody for throwing like a girl, It's adolescent, not contrarian.

More typical, hurt fanboy reaction. Stop for a moment and and think about what exactly in my comment have provoked you to attack me in this fashion.


"Stop for a moment and and think about what exactly in my comment have provoked you to attack me in this fashion"

Flashbacks to middle school.


We've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com. We're happy to unban people when there's reason to believe that they'll only post civil, substantive comments in the future.


> Sorry. We are living in a period where mediocrity and even complete fraudulent stuff is hailed as profound and "amazing".

Like what? Even the transistor is pretty damn amazing.

It's fine to be critical, but let yourself get excited sometimes too.


Check out the history of the person you're replying to. That person doesn't get stoked about anything. It's a shame, really.


Getting stoked about trivial stuff and mistaking stunts for real achievements is one of the ways we will end up in Idiocracy. I see here, a whole generation of people reduced to a bunch of stupid cheerleaders...

The shame is on you. Not because you play along in this charade. But for how you see and project me for not taking part in it.


I suppose the ultimate compliment that can be payed to the employees at SpaceX is when the successful launch of a rocket, the successful delivery to orbit of its payload, and the subsequent successful landing of it's first stage on a remotely piloted barge in the middle of the ocean can be described as trivial.

I always knew the day would come when such things would be looked at as routine and trivial, but I honestly didn't think the day would come so soon.

Perhaps HN readers such as yourself are way ahead of the curve in this regard.


That shame is fine with me. My apologies for dragging you back into a thread that is so obviously beneath you.


>Like what?

Look around. If you don't see it already, I won't be able to make you see. And what does the transistor has to do with the period we live in? I mean, right now, not 50 years earlier.

>It's fine to be critical, but let yourself get excited sometimes too.

Do you know why landing a rocket in salt water is bad. I mean, do you really, really know?

From Spacex subreddit..

https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/219sow/how_signific...


Isn't that why they are landing on a barge though?


> I mean, right now, not 50 years earlier.

I'm saying even the transistor is amazing. Be amazed!

> Do you know why landing a rocket in salt water is bad. I mean, do you really, really know?

I'm not working for SpaceX. Are you?

I didn't design the rocket. I assume they have some idea of what they're doing. They just landed a rocket on a damn barge.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: