Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>DRM will be built because the content studios demand it, and the studios hold the content which everyone wants

Why do you believe the copyright holders (or the browser makers) are the ones who potentially hold absolute power in this scenario, rather than the users? Any DRM is an unsustainable system, EME is not going to change this. I also have strong doubts that EME will do anything to push the so-called "content industry" towards better sustainability as you suggest it will. There is still zero incentive for any knowledgeable user to buy into it. If anything it will just make the system more complicated because of the proliferation of even more competing, incompatible DRM systems that only work on certain devices with very specific configuration requirements.

I agree that some of the ridiculousness in the DMCA is part of the problem, but this isn't going to be solved by building more walled gardens, it's going to be solved by thinking about how it can actually benefit the user in the long run.



> Any DRM is an unsustainable system

Agreed. Every implementation of DRM has been or will be broken eventually, and can keep people out of something that wasn't intended to be always locked.

Putting DRM on software and music is like building shitty locks into every book in the library or single in the record store. It doesn't make sense.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: