Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It's sad because we should be supportive of bold companies making difficult plays

It's not wrong to ask questions in general, although you can avoid a negative tone.

This is a special case though. They make mistakes here and people will die. Asking questions and pointing out every issue is, at some point, necessary.



> They make mistakes here and people will die.

The same problem exists for every person who enters a vehicle. That very same risk is why there is an economic incentive to do this in the first place. If they succeed far fewer people will die. And it will drive down the costs of commerce improving the quality of life for everyone.

So I take issue when the default perspective is pessimism and dismissiveness. This site is so hostile to founders who aren't doing totally safe projects or gasp those who get millions of dollars without publicly launched products.

Maybe this is just a self-selecting audience of bored pessimistic people who have time to spend commenting on their vague notions of other peoples projects on HN while the optimistic bunch is too busy building their own interesting stuff.

I find Otto a particularly interesting case because they've been pretty quiet with the contents of their tech, so we have very little idea of what they have accomplished yet other than partnering with Volvo and having lots of $$ in the bank. But I'm sure most people here would be fine commenting dismissively just off the headlines they read without really knowing any specific details of the project or the people behind it.


> "while the optimistic bunch is too busy building their own interesting stuff."

I am also dismayed by the general pessimism in this thread, though I think there is a third (and IMO most likely scenario):

Anyone who has actual direct, inside knowledge of this field will not write publicly about it for a litany of incredibly obvious competition/secrecy reasons. The people most qualified to speak on these matters are staying silent.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: