Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thick glass tends to be fairly resilient so anything that's going to damage these would likely destroy normal tiles anyway. Depending on how modular these things are they should be able to deal with breaks without significant problem just run in parallel like the good Christmas lights which still work when one goes out.


I had a ceramic roof once. Walking on the roof would break the tiles. It made it hard to do maintenance on anything up there.

My preference these days would be for a metal roof.


Corrugated iron is infamously loud in rain. What type of metal roof are you considering that wouldn't be such an earsore?


Here in NZ most roofs are corrugated iron, and people love the sound of rain on them. Different cultures...

There is another good reason for our love affair with iron - we get a lot of earthquakes. An iron roof provides a lot of structural bracing, and it's negligible weight provides much less moment than slate or tile alternatives.


Ceramic roofs are very heavy, and as you say, they don't do so well in an earthquake. The house structure has to be designed to support it.

Wood shingles rot, are slippery when moldy, are an ideal habitat for wasps, burn, and generate a demand for old growth cedar (i.e. not sustainable).


Math checks out! I'm from Europe and my roof in Auckland is corrugated iron. I hate it when it rains.

My father's business is roofing. His client once ordered dog booth made from corrugated metal. Even dog hated it during the rain.


Corrugated is only one type. Lots of places around here (Seattle) have metal shingles, and I've never noticed noise when in them in the rain. Perhaps it has to do with how they are mounted and, of course, it rarely rains hard here. It mostly just drips.

Metal roofs are light, long lasting, do not support insects, and don't burn.


This is true, but I've found that there is nothing quite like sleeping under the oddly soothing sound of heavy rain slamming against corrugated iron roofs.


If you factor in a couple thicknesses of plywood, insulation between your rafters and/or roof stringers, and the sheetrock on the ceilings of your rooms, that deadens out most of the noise.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: