Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In practice, the difference between US and other countries is still pretty big.

In US, about 60 percent of individual tax returns are filed by a professional tax preparer, at every income level. People who owe no income tax still have to file tax returns to receive tax credits. In many other modern countries, _the_majority_ of the tax payers file no tax returns at all.



60 percent? That's kinda high. Maybe force of habit, since I don't believe 60% of returns need a tax professional. TurboTax or analogous software probably can do most of the middle class returns. That's what tax preparers are use most of the time anyway - they just ask proper questions, get the docs, put them into software in the right places and file the result. May save some time, and knowing where to put the numbers requires some knowledge, so no problem with that, but I doubt it really needs that and can't be done by a good software.

> _the_majority_ of the tax payers file no tax returns at all.

I think there's a confusion here. Maybe several. First of all, in US filers and payers are not the same, as you may pay federal taxes (e.g. by deductions) and still not have to file (e.g. low income). Second, there are state taxes, which most countries don't have. Third, many countries just don't have the tax return as a thing - if you got something deducted, it's gone, good luck getting anything back. In US, you get stuff back for mortgage interest, state taxes, property taxes, charity donations, etc. etc. - you can get quite a decent amount of money back. I think it's better than just sending it over and getting nothing back, even if it could mean a bit more work.


In India mostly people prepare their own tax statement. If you are a govt official then your taxes are auto deducted AFAIK, if you are working in pvt then there is less than a three step procedure if you are willing to do your statement yourself else upload form16 on a online site to pay tax. Mostly those who earn an awfully large income use tax professionals.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: