Well the person in New York has the luxury of decent public transportation.
And the person who needs to drive, presumably they live in a suburb or a place with a yard, and they could plant 10 raspberry bushes.
Come on! Enough with the excuses! It's getting me down!
I'm not saying that people should go and sabotage themselves. I'm saying that there are lots of different things that different people can do to upset this situation.
A big one for me is not buying new if at all possible. That goes for computers, cell phones, cars, clothes, etc.
There are many other reasons why people need to drive than them working in the suburbs and globally even more reasons why biking in a city is far from enough (Just look at some Chinese cities)
The thing is that if you really were to change your life for it to have an effect we wouldn't do it. Just the threat to reliable food supply is enough to make most people accept things as they are.
There are two things you can do which are the only rational things to do.
1) Invent non-polluting, technical solutions that either produce, at scale, enough energy to replace existing solutions and which are easy to implement
2) Prepare for the consequence of climate change and find solutions to help that.
Thats what you can do. Shouting on FB, Twitter or HN doesn't help anyone.
"There are two things you can do which are the only rational things to do."
I think those are the two things that you can rationally do! But not everyone is you. I think that your focus on technical and engineering solutions is actually a "one finger points three point back" kind of situation. I think that you are probably capable in those solutions, and I encourage you to take them as strengths, not as the only solutions possible.
Here's an example, one that comes to mind, of another skillset that's going to be valuable in times to come: mediation. I live in Minnesota, where it's very cold in the winter (gets down to -30 to -40 F) and very hot in the summer (gets up to 100 to 105 F of humid heat every year). I see the effects of heat. People get violent, impatient, antsy. Stuff comes out. Pots boil over. There are is quality research into these correlations (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/01/opinion/sunday/weather-and...), so it's not just anecdotal. When times get hot around here, what we need is conversation, patience, spiritual introspection, therapies, caring people. We are going to need people with good leadership, with soft skills, who have the ability to motivate people, to guide people out of conflict, to model what's possible. Artists, parents, teachers, even just plain old solid friends who hold people together.
Okay, I'm not arguing that these are "the solutions to climate change". What I'm arguing is that they are necessary pieces of the puzzle!
"The thing is that if you really were to change your life for it to have an effect we wouldn't do it. Just the threat to reliable food supply is enough to make most people accept things as they are."
I've seen people change so drastically over the course of one lifetime, because they had to in order to survive. I've seen my religiously conservative people close to me go from being homophobic and anti-drug to being open minded and hearted. I've seen my somebody go from seriously flailing (with chronic substance issues, suicidal thoughts, body image struggles, etc) to being one of the most kick ass moms I know in 1 year flat. Don't underestimate! "When the spirit says move, move". And people will move.
P.S. I'm planning on building a web app to help people do interactively plan companion planting and permaculture gardens. If you're interested I'll let you know when I put up the source. I'll probably post it on here either way.
No i cant even do any of that and thats the point.
Instead of lulling people into the believe that human culture on its own can change things perhaps the time was better spent on the things that actually help. You havent provided anything but an emotional argument that culture can solve this, nor is there any evidence in history which points to this.
Technological progress brought us in this situation, technological progress can get us out of it.
The problem is not the individual consumer but the whole system that supports them and that wont be going anywhere as most people dont have the luxury of spending time planting or meditating.
Anecdotes on people changing is not anything but a great story. Of course people change but your argument need them to change in exactly the same way which is exactly the wrong way to understand humans. We aren't rational agents.
Couldn't agree more. I cycle 30 km every day to work and back. When I was a student, I cycled 40km every to Uni and back. You just have to get used to it.
While I own a car, I use it maybe only once per month. To get some wood or transport some things from the IKEA.
I have to admit, I live in Amsterdam, so the infrastructure for cycling is great.
And the person who needs to drive, presumably they live in a suburb or a place with a yard, and they could plant 10 raspberry bushes.
Come on! Enough with the excuses! It's getting me down!
I'm not saying that people should go and sabotage themselves. I'm saying that there are lots of different things that different people can do to upset this situation.
A big one for me is not buying new if at all possible. That goes for computers, cell phones, cars, clothes, etc.