Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Self-Medicating Animal (nytimes.com)
57 points by dnetesn on May 21, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 11 comments


Probably the most significant excerpt from the article:

The broader implication here is that some animals may be practicing a kind of science, observing cause and effect, experimenting and learning. The University of Oxford evolutionary psychologist Robin Dunbar argues in his book “The Trouble With Science” that not only is science not unique to the West or to the developed world, but that it’s not exclusive to humans. “Science is a genuine universal, characteristic of all advanced life-forms,” he writes. It’s how living things figure out the world around them.


Now all they need is to find some animals who do peer review.


I think that creating hypotheses that make predictions which are then verified by experiment is science.

Noticing that willow bark reduces pain is not the same as identifying molecular structures that block nerve receptors.


What is an advanced life form?


I guess "intelligent" seemed to loaded to describe mere animals.


But if a person does this we call them a criminal and punish them.


There are plenty of things that animals do that earn disapproval, even horror were they done by humans to other humans.

The praying mantis decapitating and devouring her mate, is one example. Infanticide and cannibalism are quite common in the animal kingdom. Many sex acts engaged at by animals and especially insects would be considered deviant if not simply insane were humans to carry them out. The list goes on and on.

That said, I'm completely against the War on Drugs. But saying animals use drugs is not a very convincing argument against it.


Not if they use the right, taxable, regulated things we tell them to!


Or crazy.


Ants do something similar:

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn28077-ant-knows-how-t...

Survival instinct is pretty strong.


Saw the headline and was expecting to see an article with a study about cats eating grass. Not so, but nevertheless an interesting read.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: