That was why I threw in the mentions of comprehensiveness, obvious organization, and obvious selection. Feist requires at least a minimum degree of creativity in the organization and selection for a compilation to be copyrightable.
A compilation whose selection criteria is, for example, "everything traded on NASDAQ" and whose organization is "order by date" seems unlikely to me to have sufficient creativity to qualify.
A compilation whose selection criteria is, for example, "everything traded on NASDAQ" and whose organization is "order by date" seems unlikely to me to have sufficient creativity to qualify.