Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> rent-and-profit

Rent and profit is a great investment for the general public. Thats not speculation, thats straight down investment.

Buy to sell is speculation, in the sense that it might not be representing the underlying risks. But even then its doubtful: if you think construction materials will rise 20% in the next year, buying your house to day and sitting on it is a sound investment, one that benefits the whole.

Speculator is an overused word to depict an enemy that kills itself.




> Thats not speculation, thats straight down investment.

You make no sense, all investment is speculation.


By what definition of investment?


The words are literally synonyms, see any dictionary.


I always think of investment as chasing the dividends and speculation as chasing the capital gains. Investors prioritize Sharpe's and alpha, while speculators are more interested in beta. Investors want to grow a business, while speculators want to make money from their money.

While they may have the same meaning in a general sense, and are synonyms from a distance, once you get up close, you can distinguish meaning between them.

That's just how English works. Huge and colossal are the same until you pull out the D&D sourcebook, and then it turns out that colossal is bigger than huge.


You can't chase dividends without risk, it's all speculation. You're making a distinction without a real difference. All investment involves risk, all investment is thus speculation. Not all speculation is investment, gambling is speculating but not investing. That's just how English works.


Those words are different in my mind. They can be the same in yours, if that's the way you prefer it. We are not beholden to the Academy of English to use words only in an officially sanctioned manner.





Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: