In an era of increased government surveilance and personal intrusion, why should Americans be ok with more oversight from a broken organization like the FCC?
The FCC is only broken in the sense that its leaders are dismantling it.
The most recent successful dismantling was getting rid of ISP customer privacy protections. ISPs are now allowed to collect data from customers without even notifying them, and sell that data.
Without a strong FCC, ISPs are quickly becoming a new "Big Brother", with similar abilities to diminish individual privacy and trust by collecting and profiting from their customer's data, and stifling competition between internet services.