Your better bet is to post the data you're evaluating and asking for opinions. You won't collect enough data to be meaningful in a post like this, so if you're limited to anecdotes and opinions, you might as well get anecdotes and opinions that relate directly to your situation.

Here's what (I think) is important to know to help you -

Role

Your years of experience

Size/function of org, assuming you don't want to name the companies

Public, or Private (and what stage)

Base

RSU or Options w/ offer

Annual Bonus potential

I'm sure you don't want to entirely out yourself, but some of that info will help you get better answers.