Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If GodTube.com, a religion-centric video site can exist, then so can TeachBook. I don't see how any company can own generic words when used as part of a phrase, even when the industry is the same. I can certainly create a company called MicroChime or YouChime or ChimeSoft.



> If GodTube.com, a religion-centric video site can exist, then so can TeachBook.

Arguably, Youtube has lost its claim on "tube" by not defending its trademark:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genericized_trademark#Avoiding_...

If Youtube had sent cease and desist letters to Godtube and other "-tubes", and escalated to court if the person hadn't ceased and desisted, it probably would have worked. (This doesn't get into the morality or cool/uncoolness or business strategy or PR aspects of it, it's just trademark law)

> I don't see how any company can own generic words when used as part of a phrase, even when the industry is the same.

Actually, that's exactly what a trademark is. Owning generic words and phrasings in the same industry.

> I can certainly create a company called MicroChime or YouChime or ChimeSoft.

Debatable. MicroChime would probably be okay if you sold small chimes. If you sold operating systems and business software, you'd absolutely get a cease and desist, and you'd almost certainly lose if it went to court. Again, this doesn't get into the morality of it, just how trademarks generally work these days.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: