Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I would consider another EV - for me that's the main I'm looking for in my next car. The reason I'm waiting for a model 3 rather than already driving a Bolt or Leaf is largely a matter of battery longevity. I want to have some assurance that the battery will not need replacing in the first 5-10 years. Tesla so far seems to be the best in that regard with their large packs and active pack management. The beauty and performance of the car are a nice plus, but even with that I'm not certain I'll wind up with a 3.


What data have you found regarding superiority of the Tesla Model 3 battery pack vs the Bolt.

From my research, the Leaf is far behind, but the Bolt and Model 3 seem very similar almost to the point where I'd guess driving style and heater usage would make up the difference.


I was basing that concern mostly on bad reports of the Leaf battery, good reports of the Tesla battery (someone put together a data set of range loss vs mileage) and lack of data on the Bolt.

I haven't seen data yet on the Bolt. The other child comment suggests it's favorable, though. If new data shows the Bolt as having similar longevity to the Tesla then it's more of a contender for me, although I don't think highly of GM or their cars in general.


All of the reports I have heard about the battery longevity of GM's Volt are very encouraging. Very few large-scale battery problems. Some users with 400K miles. GM did a good job with battery management. Presumably they continue that with the Bolt.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: