Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What is the driver supposed to say in this scenario?

"Actually officer, I saw her coming from miles away, but I thought to myself: let's just see what happens..."

Of course a "driver" in such a vehicle is going to report the victim came out of nowhere, otherwise they're basically committing homicide or implicating themselves in not paying attention and the car in not sensing them...it literally adds nothing to the evidence base...



Since it was dark out, the story seems pretty plausible. It's really difficult to see pedestrians at night, even when they use a crosswalk much less if they are crossing in the middle of the road.


The point isn't that its plausible (which it is), its that its the only story you would expect a driver who wasn't already confessing to negligence/manslaughter to say: irrespective of what actually happened.

Because if he had seen her before hand (i.e. she didn't "come out of nowhere"), he would have presumably taken control, breaked, swerved, etc.

We already know that the car appeared not to have done that, so the profession from the driver literally adds no further evidence, since that is exactly what we would expect every driver who mows down a pedestrian unwillingly to say...


You would think LIDAR might help in such a situation...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: