Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The CASE motivated tooling got in the way.

My go to joke: RationalRose is like an 800lb angry gorilla sitting between you and your work.

Alistair Cockburn did a great post mortem about that era.

Characterizing people as non-linear, first-order components in software development [1999] http://alistair.cockburn.us/Characterizing+people+as+non-lin...

During that time, I strongly preferred lo-fi paper prototyping for UI. And I'd scratch out UML diagrams. Worked fine for intra-team. But it just didn't fly with management. We had to make everything more formal and pretty.

Oh well.



It’s funny looking back at what we used to call software development methodologies. Booch and Rumbaugh were primarily focused on modeling. Any talk of process meant a dynamic description of the program.

Jacobson was a little more method focused. You can see how his introduction of use cases started the idea of talking to your customer about what they need.

I remember seeing Rose and thinking this will make a huge improvement only to be repeatedly confused and frustrated that it seemed to make everything take longer.


Finally! I get share my Booch story:

At OOPLSA 98, Booch convened the first society of software architects (or some such).

Having read all his writing (ditto Yourdon, Brooks, Rumblaugh, etc), I was super excited.

During the Q&A I finally got to ask “What is software architecture?”

Booch replied “Software architecture is what software architects do.”

Bubble popped.

I gave up seeking the council of the priesthood and blazed my own path.


Wow. In some ways, that's the worst possible answer. In my view, software architecture is what every developer contributes to, which means we have to be thoughtful about how we collaborate on it.

Every time I see a shop with designated Software Architects who hog the architecture work, it's a fucking mess. Because then Software Architects don't get rewarded in their careers for making software. They get rewarded for writing white papers and coming up with "brilliant" architectures and impressing executives who know less than them about technology. Which is mostly inversely correlated with actually making it easier for developers to get real work done.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: