Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The unavoidable suggested answers in gmail make my skin crawl. I dont want it and i dont want to be reminded that you can read my emails despite my consent for it

I guess it's a good reminder that i need to change services



How can an email service work without "reading" your email? Emails need to be indexed to be searcheable etc.


It does not need to read the body of email in order to work. It can index just the header(to, date, subject) or you can use a program on your computer locally to keep your emails and index&search them.


> It does not need to read the body of email in order to work. It can index just the header(to, date, subject) The header is still personal data. Using the header but avoiding the body does not make much sense.

Again, "reading" emails seems to be an arbitrary distinction. Your emails are stored and served to you, so they are read by HTTP servers, by your browser, by many things. The real issue is the use that is made of those readers: an index that allows you to search your emails more efficiently does not seem to be nefarious, but I definitely agree that other nefarious uses are possible (say some company that would use emails to target people in debt or something like that), just not the case with Gmail.

> You can use a program on your computer locally to keep your emails and index&search them.

Right, but then it's not Gmail anymore, that's just an IMAP mail server with Thunderbird. Gmail started as a smart webmail; being able to quickly search your emails from anywhere, without a desktop client, without fetching thousands of emails before you could perform a search.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: