If your 20 you have up to 100 years worth of investing horizons to consider. Money put to retirement really is something you can lose while young. Investing in low enough to be zero yield instruments like CD's or savings accounts is terrible advice. As is treating investment savings as actual savings you can spend.
Sure, keeping ~3 years income outside of the market if your actually retired is a good idea idea. But, just because the market tanked does not mean you lost money. You have the same share of the same companies if the market goes up or down.
"If your 20 you have up to 100 years worth of investing horizons to consider. Money put to retirement really is something you can lose while young. Investing in low enough to be zero yield instruments like CD's or savings accounts is terrible advice. As is treating investment savings as actual savings you can spend."
If you need the money in five years, you should not be putting it in the stock market. If the money is truly "put to retirement" then you don't need it in five years, and you're just agreeing with me, pedantically.
The problem is that most of these HODL folks have never lived through a downturn, and will be crapping their pants when they realize that they really were secretly counting on the money being there. I've seen it happen twice now. The forums are filled with people "buying the dips" on 1% drops, but suddenly seeing a 30% short-term correction in their portfolio causes mass hysteria. The smart players have cash
on hand, and are ready to buy -- precisely because they didn't "buy the dips".
Cost dollar averaging already does a fairly good job of timing the market via retirement savings. Trying to beat that is a terrible idea, as being out of the market for a few days can easily cost you a year of growth.
He is also running an insurance company that needs cash on hand. On top of that they don't issue dividends only occasional stock buybacks which means they are going to accumulate cash by default.
Sure, keeping ~3 years income outside of the market if your actually retired is a good idea idea. But, just because the market tanked does not mean you lost money. You have the same share of the same companies if the market goes up or down.