Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Considering people keep toilets for 5-10 years per toilet on average and the cost of a toilet is much less than the cost of an electrical bidet... It is not a great idea.


5-10 years? Is that the life expectancy of the average modern toilet?

From personal experience that seems off by a few decades.


I have never actually heard of anyone buying a new toilet. I'm sure it happens, but 5-10 years? My parents' house still has the same toilet it had when they moved in 30-odd years ago, and it works as well as it ever did.

Also, I dunno about the electrical ones, but you can get a non-electric bidet for like $25 off Amazon. Maybe a bit more for one with hot and cold hook-ups and a temperature knob. You just run it with the nozzle aimed down until it warms up.


In general I agree with you regarding the lifetime, the exceptions are areas that goes through expanding housing prices.

For example, good luck finding a bathroom in a central Stockholm flat that is more than 5 years old due to the housing market 2000-2017.

The amount of money spent on bathroom remodels really baffles me. Credit expansion made people throw out new bathrooms, redo them and then revaluate their flat to make the mortgage cover the cost.

A nice bathroom renovation cost about $27k while the net annual salary probably is around $40k.

Due to this, my bet is that the people depending on bathroom remodels are the people that will get squeezed first now when the housing market has turned bearish.


I bought three toilets when I bought my house, because the ones there were here didn't work. My in-laws bought a few toilets a couple years ago because theirs sprung a leak in the tank that was unfixable. Also, the water company gave rebates if you switched out your old one for a new efficient one.

I assume a lot of people buy toilets every day, otherwise Home Depot wouldn't have an entire aisle dedicated to them...


People build new houses, extend their current ones, replace broken ones. I'd still bet on the average lifetime of one to be over 20 years...


> people keep toilets for 5-10 years per toilet on average

Do you have any data to back this up? I would have assumed it was far less often.


Yah, who the heck is turning over their toilets twice a decade? Best guess here is 25 year average service life.


Then that only proves my point further.

Toilets in my family would get replaced every 15 years.


And what connection could it possibly have to installation of a bidet seat?!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: