Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> This is one reason why every winter the National Health Service runs campaigns telling people "do you really need to see your doctor?" and poor people in particular go "yes we do".

The other reason (At least in the US and Canada) for why poor/'poor' people go and see their doctor when they have a cold, is because their boss expects a doctor's note for a sick-with-the-cold day.

Such campaigns are as much targeted at the patient, as it is at their employers. Doctors don't want to deal with non-serious seasonal infections, and they don't want patients seeking a doctor's note to get their other patients sick.



Been there, done that.

Phoned up work to tell them I was on the first day of a bad cold and needed a day off. They say no problem but you MUST get a doctor's note. So I phone the GP and they tell me they can see me in 2 weeks' time, I go along as ordered - the cold's completely better by then of course - and ask for a note to say that I had a cold 2 weeks ago, which I duly get and hand in to my employer. Everyone's happy, free at the point of service etc.


Your GP was allowed to charge you for that letter, and if you were inside the self-certification time your employer must pay the charge.


Which country does this apply to?


England. Sorry, I should have said. I don't know what happens in Wales or Scotland or NI.


I hope you made a point of asking for two hours off that day, to sit in the waiting room for a note to make HR happy.


Employers in the UK aren't supposed to ask for one if it's less than seven days (I don't know if they aren't allowed to, but I and my immediate family have never worked anywhere they have):

> If you're off work sick for seven days or less, your employer shouldn't ask for medical evidence that you've been ill. Instead they can ask you to confirm that you've been ill.

https://www.nhs.uk/common-health-questions/caring-carers-and...

GPs can charge if it is for less than seven days.


yes, thank you. Fortunately I no longer work for employers like that, but as an entry-level low-level employee, you are automatically looked at with suspicion by most employers. If you need a sick day, you have to get a doctor's note, which is an outrageous waste of everybody's resources.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: