Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'll say it goes further than that.

I have a few modular power supplies around from different vendors, and I made the mistake of using one cable in a different vendors supply.

The supply side had the same connections; so I thought that I could just mix-and-match.

Turns out, that even though the connections are standardized, I ended up putting ground on a 5v pin, 12v on the 5v, 3.3v on the 3.3v (magically) and 5v on the 12v pin on a standard SATA connector.

As a result, I fried several hard drives, because the output of the supplies wasn't standardized for the connector type. I can't even imagine an end-user using a volt-meter to check which are compatible with which vendor.

This was a problem before USB-C.

TL;DL: Check your modular supply cables, and don't use other vendors cables.



There is no standard for modular power supply cables.

USB-C on the other hand is a standard.


They have the same form-factor for the connectors; I'd say that's a standard; especially since they are polarized plugs (full square, trapezoid.)


You're describing the problem that USB is supposed to solve.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: