Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not true.

The first Model 3 arrived in Switzerland in the 3rd week of February (2019-02-16). Tesla already sold 316 in February 2019 (+754% YoY).

How much of an exceptional month March will be for the year, we'll see after the April data is released. The number of preorders for Model 3 in Switzerland should be easily 1 order of magnitude higher than what they delivered in March.



> Tesla already sold 316 in February 2019 (+754% YoY).

I'm sure that's not your intention but please don't quote % numbers like this because it is extremely misleading and has zero indicative value. Going from selling one car to selling 100 is a 10000% increase. Is that a meaningful figure? No. All it does is inflate the percieved growth and makes the post look biased and suspect of having an agenda.

Values that are useful in such a context is the number of cars sold from other makers in the same segment or the growth of new models from other brands.


If that YoY figure is for Model 3s in Switzerland, then you really can't quote it as a figure with any statistical honesty. A year from first delivery hasn't even elapsed yet.


How is it definitely "not true" if your position is to just wait and see until April ?

And not sure why YoY numbers are important given that it's a cheaper car being sold here. Of course it's going to be higher. Problem of course is a lot less margin.


> How is it definitely "not true" if your position is to just wait and see until April ?

"All the Tesla 3 preorders arrived [1][2] in Switzerland in one month" is of course complete nonsense. Because not only did plenty arrive in February already, but the preorders were much higher than what came in March.


I love your "The recent trend of ideologically motivated downvoting of factual arguments [...]" and then downvoting on ideological grounds with "+754%" right out "How to Lie with Statistics". Looking at the graph in the article shows the whole picture.


> then downvoting on ideological grounds

I downvoted a clearly factually wrong statement, namely that "all preorders were delivered in one month".

The "754%" were a direct quote, source above, that indicates clearly that March wasn't the first (and only) month with increased sales due to the Model 3. Individual sales figures for the Model 3 were not available to me, otherwise I would have posted them (my estimate is around 280-300).


The "all preorders" was a generalization for "the peak of a steep Gauss curve was in one month". At least that was my explanation. What would be yours? Most people in Switzerland suddenly bought Model3s instead of VM Golfs in February?


Your comment contains exact numbers why not also put the source where you found them?



Thank you


This is probably a Gauss curve with some early, then peaking, then going down again.


source https://www.auto.swiss/home/

I'm sure those numbers will drop a lot.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: