Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> At 5 millibars (5,000 ppm), you would start breathing at a 10% elevated rate, which you probably wouldn’t notice.

Wouldn't you? Won't you subconsciously notice and want to end the meeting faster?

Imagine breathing at an elevated rate in a crowded room that lacks proper ventilation. There's more than co2 coming from the human body. People will begin sweating, farting, etc., and fill the air with all kinds of pollutants. The computers, screens, dry erase board, etc. will make the situation even worst.

I know that such a room will make me want to make quick decisions to leave quickly.



You're referring to a psychological effect, he's referring to an autonomic. It's the same way the you don't tend to notice your heart rate increase and decrease as you move around unless it's major.


The opening post was about a psychological effect to which this poster responded "No. I wrote up the computations explaining why." and linked to a paper which had as a conclusion an increase in breathing rates.

My point is that a crowded room likely has more than one causes which could explain why productivity is lowered and decisions making worsened.

You won't notice an autonomic response but your brain likely will and it might very well answer by releasing adrenaline, cortisol, etc., and make you more anxious and stressed to encourage you to leave the environment that is causing the increased breathing rates.


>Imagine breathing at an elevated rate in a crowded room that lacks proper ventilation. There's more than co2 coming from the human body. People will begin sweating, farting, etc., and fill the air with all kinds of pollutants. The computers, screens, dry erase board, etc. will make the situation even worst.

Your description makes me think of the opening scene from Falling Down.[0]

[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=piPzExBdfIg




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: