Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wouldn't claiming non-military involvement embolden the protesters?


Protesters are already facing threats of physical violence, so saying that there won't be overt military action isn't likely to change many minds. Dozens have been injured in altercations with the Hong Kong police department since protests started last month. There have been several accusations of police brutality, coming from both protesters and journalists. There are also accusations that the police are already using the PLA or other forces from the mainland to bolster their ranks, but it's hard for me to tell how likely that is too be true. The primary pieces of evidence that I hear are officers covering or wearing incorrect identification numbers, and officers speaking little/no Cantonese & speaking Mandarin instead.


Not sure the protesters would do much differently until they saw military action, or lack of it.

I don't think a news story changes much.


Many of the front-line protesters seem to be willing to give up their lives to confront the HK government.

They broke into the LegCo building on 1/July, if the police force hasn't withdrawn, probably lots of blood would have been shed.

Whether one agrees or not, many of the youth do not see much, if any, hope in Hong Kong under the current leadership.

These people would rather go "scorched earth" (well, probably not Syrian-style scorched earth, yet) than to be appeased with empty promises, again.


Which would then give them an excuse to send in the military.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: