Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Ride-hailing drivers hailed the bill’s passage." - I wonder how happy they will be when their job simply goes away because of that bill.

It's terribly misguided and anti-freedom.

I think it is a problem if companies like Uber are not honest with their employees, like neglecting to mention that their cars may break down and require maintenance, which should be factored into the income. But that is about honest information sharing, not forced employment.

Nevertheless, people should be free to do contract work and negotiate contracts on their own terms.



> "I wonder how happy they will be when their job simply goes away because of that bill."

Taxis are... not "going away". They may get more expensive. Taxi companies are simply going to make a comeback.

Uber was making it easier/cheaper for passangers - it did very little for the drivers themselves.


Uber is not Taxi. OP point is still correct. Taxi companies are coming back but Uber drivers get fired.


> "Uber is not Taxi. OP point is still correct. Taxi companies are coming back but Uber drivers get fired"

They can't be "fired", since they were never properly hired in the first place! They were never regarded as employees. That's exactly what this legislation is setting out to change!


It doesn't matter how you call it - they will be unable to earn extra money by driving, that is the issue. If they relied on that money to make ends meet, they may not be happy anymore.


> "It doesn't matter how you call it - they will be unable to earn extra money by driving, that is the issue. If they relied on that money to make ends meet, they may not be happy anymore."

Your post makes zero sense, so I'll keep it short for you. Uber was the middleman, and without it - both individual drivers as-well as taxi companies have significantly more leverage over the consumers, and can now start charging higher prices.


My post makes zero sense? Are you sure you have thought things through?

So how does a driver get clients without Uber? If they can get clients without Uber, why did they use Uber?

How do clients know they can trust a driver? Taxi, OK - a taxi driver has to shell out serious money to get a license. Sometimes they must show proof of training. That makes them somewhat trustworthy, especially since their license can be revoked after a transgression.

For Uber, I suppose they tried to replace that with a rating system.

Without Uber, how do you propose making it work? I suspect simply becoming taxi drivers is not a viable option for many Uber drivers - because of the time and money commitment.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: