Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What if I write a program that does that translation agnostically of the specific work being translated?

And what if my program is parametrized by an ML model of unknown training data?



> What if I write a program that does that translation agnostically of the specific work being translated?

Then that program will likely produce non-copyrighted output for non-copyrighted input. But it's also likely going to sound pretty bad.

> And what if my program is parametrized by an ML model of unknown training data?

Then its output could be considered a derivative work of every work in that training corpus, and anyone whose creative work went into that training data will have a copyright claim on the results.


> Then its output could be considered a derivative work of every work in that training corpus, and anyone whose creative work went into that training data will have a copyright claim on the results.

Depends how tech savvy the judge is. An ML model is not really like a copy or reproduction, it's much more like a person's brain in that it aims to take general patterns from various sources.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: