Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Analog Devices to acquire Maxim Integrated (wsj.com)
11 points by fermienrico on July 12, 2020 | hide | past | favorite | 5 comments


Best case scenario, Analog eats Maxim and fires their entire management and product teams... or more. Worst case scenario is a Boeing-McDonnell Douglas style merger where Maxim is left running the show. That would essentially remove ADI as a viable product option, so let's hope they're smarter than that.

(Which they were, when ADI bought LTC. That merger has gone about as well as these things can, for customers. The difference between LTC and Maxim, though, is that LTC was best-in-class on every feature save price, whereas Maxim... friends don't let friends design in Maxim. They're no good for you unless you're an Apple or Qualcomm.)


> whereas Maxim... friends don't let friends design in Maxim.

I design occasionally as a hobby. My designer friends would tell me the same. What is the reason? I have found their documentation and application notes pretty good and their MAX232 and other convertor ICs are very popular.


See sibling comment. Short version: those are their high-volume, low-margin old parts. Their high-margin new parts are the problem.


I have a few project ideas, and I’ve been looking at Maxim chips for some portions. What’s wrong with them?


Search the EEVblog forums for more people (myself included) hating on Maxim. Here's one thread: https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/maxim-love-_em-or-hat...

Suffice it to say that supply is awful. Often your choices are (1) what's in stock today at distributors or (2) how many wafers per month are you going to buy from us (and it better be a lot)? Plus there are a fair few datasheets under NDA and parts that make no sense; those are obviously semi-customs for some customer that made it to the general market somehow.

These days the only Maxim parts I'll design in are ones that have second sources (like standard package op-amps). Their RTCs and voltage references have historically been okay, but I still try to avoid them: once bitten, twice shy....




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: