Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because Bhopal had nothing to do with energy production? And are you claiming Bhopal didn't get massive media coverage? Because it did.


I know, Bhopal was a chemical processing plant. But it was a massive disaster, that killed thousands, and nobody came out of that saying we should never process chemicals.


Perhaps we shouldn't mass produce deadly environmentally destructive pesticides either? Would that be a bold statement?

Why do you keep changing the subject? Quit talking about coal and pesticides and explain why it's okay to risk the lives of entire cities of people for the sake of extra electric output?

Edit: I never disagreed with the article's title. I was agreeing with the parent post's sentiment that regardless of the numbers, downplaying the suffering of the people in Fukushima and the risks they still face is wrong. Nuclear power is dangerous and can have terrible costs. It's entirely reasonable not to view it as a praiseworthy technology.


"Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity"

In case you are unversed in the nuanced English being used here, "safe" != "safest", nor are their meanings equivalent. So why do you keep changing the subject?

Nuclear isn't 'safe', but it is the 'safest'. Modern society assumes some amount of risk, get over it.


why it's okay to risk the lives of entire cities of people for the sake of extra electric output?

Do you not understand, that's the exact reason why people are bringing up coal.

If we were to switch off of coal and onto nuclear, scores less people would die and get sick. A massive amount. Not to mention the benefits of halting climate change.

That doesn't mean nuclear is all sunshine and rainbows, and nobody who reasonably supports nuclear over coal thinks that.


You don't know enough to make that statement. If you replace coal with PWR nuclear reactors, you still have potential problems. You are projecting past performance into the future which is extremely foolish.


Deepwater Horizon would have made a much better example, I think.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: