This has been going back and forth too much. I am not even sure why single person (judge) wants to make such sweeping decisions. These drivers work on their own whims. They may decide to show up or not. They can cut short day anytime. Uber or Lyft don’t require them to start their shifts and work 40 hours a day. The drivers don’t commit to any full time work schedule. So at best things are muddy and lawmakers needs to come together instead of individual judges start writing laws according to their individual whims and philosophy. This will most definitely be get challenged and ultimately SC will not want to hear this anyway so it’s just massive waste of time for everyone. Only lawyers are getting rich in the process.