Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yep. Police Forces really need to reform these silly baseless psuedo-science ideas.


Given that they end up with a breath test anyway, either there on at the station, and the field sobriety isn't typically admissible, I suspect that they do it for other reasons. It's either theatre to intimidate the suspect, or an excuse for overtime for the other 2-4 offices that show up


> Given that they end up with a breath test anyway

You might not have a lot of say in whether you’re taken in for a breath test, but that doesn’t make it admissible in court. A cop only needs reasonable suspicion to pull you over and ask if you’re drunk. A cop needs probable cause to arrest you for breath test.

The purpose of the field sobriety test is to help with the probable cause part. It’s also worth noting that (in the US at least), you are never under any obligation to participate in one. Refusing one can’t be weighed against you as probable cause, and participating in one will never help you. Especially considering police will judge as sober field sobriety test participant as impaired about 50% of the time.

Roadside breath tests are quite a different matter though. But they’re still used for the same purpose. The actual evidential test will be a blood/breath test performed after arrest.


I imagine it's fun for the officers to watch a drunk person try these things too.


Yes, they’ve already made up their mind about what they want to do, so once you’re suspected the testing is just a formality.


It's more than that.

When it becomes just a breath test, next step is to set up road blocks and breath test everyone. We know because it happens in countries.

The idea is human beings should be considered innocent by default and allowed to live their lives without being medically tested at random.

Suspicion -> suspicion -> breath test -> blood test.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: