Wouldn’t that mean an end to a lot of free services?
They are not free, you pay for them with everything you buy, with the ad budget share of the price. And you are not only paying for the service you want, you are also paying for the entire ad industry on top of that.
Whatever the cost, it will increase significantly without advertising. Advertising pushes product into more hands which makes unit costs lower. Targeted advertising reduces ad costs because they are more effective.
Free services have no reason to exist without advertising.
Advertising pushes product into more hands which makes unit costs lower.
This is at the very least not obvious. Advertising does, again at least not obviously, increase the amount of money consumers [can] spend. If they shift money to one product, another one will see reduced consumption and get more expensive to manufacture.
Also what prevents one or a few companies from being very successful with their advertisement, becoming a oligopoly or even a monopoly and then inflating the price for more profit and to the disadvantage of the consumers?
>Also what prevents one or a few companies from being very successful with their advertisement, becoming a oligopoly or even a monopoly and then inflating the price for more profit and to the disadvantage of the consumers?
I think this is just as muddy as the bits you pointed out. Incumbents don't need to advertise but new players do and they have a better chance to gain market share with targeted advertising due to more effective use of their often limited budgets.
I think this is just as muddy as the bits you pointed out.
You are of course right, I only wanted to given some scenario with opposite outcome for customers. My point was more that one will have to provide much better arguments or evidence than some random macroeconomic interaction to convince me that advertising has any net positive effect.
They are not free, you pay for them with everything you buy, with the ad budget share of the price. And you are not only paying for the service you want, you are also paying for the entire ad industry on top of that.