Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Maybe not that specific example, but the situation of listening to Indian film music is a classic case of folders being 100% inadequate.

Any given Indian movie corresponds to an 'album' of songs. However, each song can in the album have a different set of artistes associated with it. Hell, sometimes there are multiple composers within the same movie's soundtrack. And Indian movie soundtracks are more tightly coupled than "Western" movie OST albums, so you can't just treat them as an independent collection of songs either. (Indians typically identify songs first with the movies they appeared in, rather than the composer or performer)

Basically, a majority of Indian movies are musicals - and a simple folder structure is just not enough to deal with such a collection of music!




I don't understand... do you not typically want to listen to the soundtrack in the order it was in the movie (that is, exactly the case in which a single folder for the soundtrack excels)? If not, how?


Confusingly enough - no. From what I do [and what I've seen most people do], there's an equal split between listening to:

1) All songs from the movie

2) All songs by the composer(s) (or 'music director')

3) All songs by the singer(s)

...with other edge cases like a specific combination of composer and singer, the decade of movie release, genre or even by the movie director.

ID3 tags and smart playlists are a frickin boon to managing a large set of Indian film music!




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: