Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The sheer ignorance of this statement:

"The myth, as is commonly told, tells the story of a mid-twentieth century world headed for disaster. There were too many people being born and not enough food being produced. This combination of forces would lead inexorably to famine, unchecked migration, conflict and other calamities. However, thanks to the inventiveness of Western scientists more food was produced, Armageddon was avoided, and the world did not experience a population crisis."

But also thanks to the green revolution we have pesticides and fertilisers that made this happen, that are causing cancer all over Punjab and created massive wealth disparities. Not to mention we never needed all this food, if the population was in control. But the population exploded because of Western invasions that resulted in mass poverty!

Thanks "western" scientists!



The article agrees with you. It was all a ruse to satisfy US domestic political concerns. As were/are a lot of the 20th Century world "problems", it is becoming apparent.


Really makes you think


> But the population exploded because of Western invasions that resulted in mass poverty!

I disagree. IMO it exploded because improvements in medical care resulted in a dramatic reduction in child deaths, but people kept having the same number of children.


The Indian population went from 50 million to 300 million under British rule, then tripled again after 20-30 years when most did not have access to that medical care.


Who told (Indian) Punjab to hook up electric pumps to tube wells 24/7 and destroy/deplete their aquifers?


Intensive farming did, to get most out of the soil as pesticides and fertilisters drove all that need for extra water


There aren't "western" or "eastern" or "southern" scientists.

There are just scientists.

And deal with that chip.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: