Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"To appear" has a technical meaning in academia, though—it doesn't mean "I hope"; it means "it's been formally accepted but hasn't actually been put in 'print' yet."

That doesn't stop someone from lying about it, but it's not a casual claim, and doing so would probably bring community censure (as well as being easily falsifiable after time).



"To appear" to me meant; it is under revision by IEEE, otherwise why not just to state paper was accepted by IEEE.


It is a bit more complicated, since this is a conference paper. Usually, if a conference paper is accepted, it is only published if the presentation was held (so if the speaker cancels, or doesnt show up, the publication is revoked).

Edit: All conference are different, I dont know if it applies to that one.


I have only ever attended one conference, but I attended it about 32 times, and the printed proceedings were in my hands before I attended any talks in the last dozen or so. How does revocation work in that event?


Well, it depends on the conference. I know this to be true for a certain IEEE conference, so I assumed it to be the same for this IEEE one, but I have to admit, I didnt check. You are right, I also remember the handouts at a different conference handed on a usb stick at arrival.


It makes sense, thank you for explanation.


It's a jargon in academia.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: