I think the whole point of it being central is that it's not verified by everyone. "Everyone" doesn't have the force of law without getting into politics, but that "central" body does.
It doesn't make a difference if 51% of my neighbors think the house belongs to me, it matters who is going to get removed for trespassing. That's the problem people have with blockchain, it doesn't matter what the blockchain says, because the blockchain can't enforce anything. If the blockchain could mindlessly enforce anything, I would own your house if I stole the private key. If you need a 3rd party to be able to make a judgement call and unwind legal situations, then the power resides in them, making the blockchain just a database with extra steps. You can make a database open and "verifiable" by anyone (like property tax records) without a blockchain.
