Can you give an example? The rules for CSV files are so simple I'm struggling to imagine a case where something looks correct but in fact isn't correct.
That sounds like the problem of badly formatted CSV, not a problem with CSV per se.
If you stick to one delimiter, and that delimiter is a comma, and escape the delimiter in the data with double-quotes around the entry, and escape double quotes with two double-quotes, well, you have written CSV that is correct and looks correct and will be parsed correctly by literally every CSV parser.
That's really not a serious argument against CSV. Since you paraphrase in a silly way, I can do it too! Your "argument" is "Badly formatted files exist, therefore CSV bad".
Everyone "against CSV" seems to be arguing against badly formatted CSV, and leaping to the conclusion that "CSV is just bad" without much more to say about it. I'm sorry that badly formatted CSV gave you a bad time, but the format is fine and gets its job done.
"It doesn't have x, y or z feature therefore no one should be using it ever" is kind of a dumb argument, honestly.
> Your "argument" is "Badly formatted files exist, therefore CSV bad".
The argument is actually that the badly formatted CSV files have taken over, therefore CSV is bad. You can't reject them, so your import becomes unreliable.
Me, a naive idiot: CSV is simple I will write my own exporter because I am clever
Me, 20 minutes later: Heh that was easy I am a genius
Me, 21 minutes later: Unicode is ruining my life T_T
Don't get me wrong, I really like CSV because it's so primitive and works so well if you are disciplined about it. But it's easy to get something working on a small dataset and forget all the other possibilities only to faceplant as soon as you step outside your front door. In the case above my experience with dealing with CSV data from other people made me arrogant, when I should have just taken a few minutes to learn my way around a mature library.
In UTF-8, the byte for a comma and a quote only exist as their characters. They don't exist as parts of multibyte sequences, by design.
If you have Unicode problems, then you have Unicode problems, but they wouldn't seem to be CSV problems...? Unless you're being incredibly sloppy in your programming and outputting double-byte UTF-16 strings surrounded by single-byte commas and quotes or something...?
If you're manually generating your own CSV files, you probably know what kind of data you are generating and consequently whether your data is going to contain commas. If commas and newlines don't exist in your data, then you can safely ignore quoting rules when generating CSV files. I know that I've generated CSVs in the past and rather than figuring out the correct way to quote the strings, I just removed any inconvenient characters without any loss to the data at all. Obviously this is not "correct" but you don't have to implement cases if you know they won't show up.
