Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A variant of #1 or, usually, #2: most of the time when you "buy" a digital good, you're really renting it out under extremely limiting terms.


I got your point, it's valid, specially membership sites. But some stuff is different. Ebooks, audio files.


It's still correct regarding ebooks and audio files, you're not paying for the files but the rights to keep a copy of the file and use it personally.

If the files are not protected by DRM, then there's no technical limitation on copying or redistributing the file, but according to your license agreement you're not permitted to do so.

In practice, no one is probably going to come after you for copying your music files or ebooks across your devices or sharing it with friends, but you don't own the file. Try mass distributing it or reselling it long enough and you'll attract someone's attention.


Which ebooks and audio files? Two mainstream providers - Amazon (Kindle) and Spotify - both rent out access, not sell actual ebooks.


I bought a lot such files on various web pages. I am not sure what your question is. Good point re Kindle/Spotify.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: